This post is way overdue. I planned and started it at least a month ago, but then political commentaries and travel stories displaced it. So, here’s me going back in my own lane – psychology.
If you missed my last three posts, they were:
What Survives When Empires Fall (a travel story with pictures)
Full Pockets, Empty Promises (on the politics of corruption)
Rage Bait – The Word Of The Year (cultural psychology)
George Bonanno, a professor of clinical psychology at Columbia University, has spent decades tracking people after bereavement, disaster, and violence in his clinical research. He’s introduced innovations in trauma research, written books on the subject, and won multiple awards for his contributions to understanding trauma. In the last five years, he has been ranked among the top 1% of most frequently cited scientists among all science and social-science disciplines worldwide.
George Bonanno is not shy about busting the most common myths about trauma that most therapists and our therapy culture take as gospel. I don’t consider myself a trauma specialist, but I am reluctant to label anything and everything that people struggle with as trauma-related, if for no other reason than to avoid getting people stuck in what they think is an inescapable past.
A lot of science is on his side.
Myth 1: “Anything very difficult or hard can cause trauma.”
Bonanno’s point: many difficult or painful events are stressful or unpleasant, but “trauma” in the psychiatric sense means exposure to actual or threatened death, serious injury, or sexual violence (DSM-5 criterion A for PTSD). He explicitly pushes back on the idea that every breakup, job loss, or mean comment is “trauma” in the PTSD sense.
That doesn’t mean those experiences are trivial; it means they’re not all pathological.
“Trauma” is more than PTSD, but PTSD is the most precise, clinically defined form of trauma-related pathology. Most confusion comes from people using one word to mean three different things.
First, in psychiatry and clinical psychology, trauma is not a feeling and not simply “something hard.” It is defined by exposure, not reaction. An exposure to a potentially traumatic event (PTE) can be direct (it happened to you), witnessed, or indirect but repeated, as in the case of first responders exposed to horrifying events regularly.
This definition exists only to determine eligibility for trauma-related disorders, especially PTSD. It’s important to understand that an event can be traumatic without causing PTSD, and PTSD is a specific outcome, not the event itself.
Many people experience traumatic events and show distress that resolves naturally; others show little disruption at all. A traumatic event does not equal damage, pathology, or PTSD—it only means a high-stress exposure occurred.
Second, trauma as a psychological injury (disorder or syndrome) is an outcome, most precisely captured by PTSD and related disorders. Here, trauma refers to a specific pattern of persistent symptoms, such as intrusions, avoidance, negative mood/cognition changes, and hyperarousal lasting longer than one month and impairing functioning. This is not a universal result of trauma exposure. It occurs in a minority of people. PTSD is real, serious, and well-validated, but it is one possible trajectory, not the default human response to adversity.
Third, trauma as a subjective or developmental experience, not diagnosable in the clinical sense, is the broad, modern usage of trauma, covering chronic stress, developmental adversity, attachment disruptions, repeated interpersonal harm, or experiences that overwhelm coping, especially in childhood. It can shape emotion regulation, relationships, and self-concept without meeting PTSD criteria.
This category includes what is often called complex or developmental trauma. It is clinically meaningful but heterogeneous, lacks a single diagnostic boundary, and does not imply permanent damage. Outcomes range from impairment to resilience, depending on context, support, and later life experiences.
Myth 2: “Anything we call trauma causes lasting emotional damage.”
In Remarkable Resiliency: George Bonanno on PTSD, Grief, and Depression, Bonanno looked into a sample of 2,752 New Yorkers after 9/11 and found that about 65% showed a resilient trajectory (little or no PTSD symptoms six months later), even if they were directly exposed.
Resiliency in the face of traumatic events is often assumed to be rare, to the point that those who don’t have a marked reaction to loss or suffering may even be said to be lying to themselves, or otherwise repressing their emotions, Bonanno explained. In reality, people are often remarkably resilient.
…Optimism is just one of numerous factors that can contribute to an individual’s likelihood of remaining resilient in the face of trauma. Resilient individuals often possess greater regulatory flexibility, which helps them to develop and apply a more diverse range of coping strategies, Bonanno said.
Even though potentially traumatic events are common, chronic PTSD and lasting severe impairment are not the default outcome. A 2022 meta-analysis of 78 studies with 16,484 participants showed that PTSD rates were around 27% at one month after trauma but dropped to 18% at three months, with significant spontaneous recovery without treatment.
Bonanno’s 2004 American Psychologist paper sums it up: resilience is not rare; it’s probably the most common trajectory after loss or trauma, and there are multiple and sometimes unexpected pathways to resilience.
Myth 3: “We all carry hidden traumas that secretly control us.”

